Tony's Pizza - Galloway: Authentic, Homemade Italian Pizza & More in Ohio

My husband discovered this pizza shop a couple of weeks ago and loved it, so he recommended we come back for lunch today. I’m so glad we did! The food was absolutely delicious. They had a sign saying everything is homemade—which is rare these days—and you can definitely tell it’s true. The bread on our Italian sub was perfectly fluffy with a nice crisp bite, and it was loaded with plenty of cheese and meat. Fresh, hearty, and full of flavor. We’ll definitely be coming back again!

This was one of the best pizza experiences we have had outside of Italy! Our family is constantly on the hunt for the best American pizza to satisfy our pizza craving until we can get back to our favorite place to visit. It’s very difficult to impress us but this was incredible. We ordered via DoorDash and usually places don’t live up to our expectations. It was still hot when it got to us and everything was flavorful and cooked beautifully. Try them!

I DoorDashed Tony’s Italian Pizza and was seriously impressed. I ordered the 12-inch pepperoni pizza and mozzarella sticks—both were absolutely delicious and arrived piping hot. The pizza had that perfect balance of crispy crust, savory sauce, and plenty of pepperoni. The mozzarella sticks were golden, gooey, and full of flavor. Will definitely be ordering again soon!

My kids and I heard about Tony's two days ago from a friend and had to go over ASAP! It's New York *like* but a little more of a crispy crust, but it was SO good, we failed to take multiple pictures! :) The kids got the garlic knots and loved them. Cheese pizza pictured for the kids. I got my classic jalapeño and pineapple. It was fantastic. There are only two tables in there, so it's obviously geared for takeout, but my two kids and I ate in and chatted with the owner and his wife. They were so nice and friendly. We can't wait to go back and try the strombolis!

I had an absolutely fantastic experience at Tony’s Pizza on 946 Galloway Rd, Galloway, OH 43119! This family-owned gem truly made me feel like part of their family from the moment I walked in. I ordered two burgers and mozzarella sticks, and everything was beyond delicious—the mozzarella sticks had an incredible cheese pull that was just perfection! The burgers were cooked to juicy, flavorful goodness, and the quality was top-notch. To top it off, I got two sodas, and they even threw in an extra one for free, which was such a kind gesture. The price was unbeatable for the quality and portion size, making it an incredible value. The warm, welcoming atmosphere and friendly service made the whole experience unforgettable. I’m already looking forward to my next visit—Tony’s Pizza has earned a loyal customer in me! Five stars all the way!

So tired of the whole midwest cracker crust square cut pizza thing when I seen Tony's advertised New York style pizza I thought ok whatever another attempt at a classic style pizza. But I gotta say I am pretty happy with the quality of pie I got the crust had a nice crispness to it but still maintained a good chew as well, the pie had just enough sauce to know that it was there, Pepperoni was delicious not too spicy and did not produce a lot of grease. the calzone was perfect (meat lovers) had the proper amount of ricotta just the way God intended. I Will definitely return to try more items and wish Tony's Pizza much success

Everyone needs to try this place! Full disclosure: I've never eaten pizza in New York. But I have eaten pizza probably a thousand times in my life, and this is near the top of all of the pizzas I've ever had. Thin but still crispy crust; almost over-loaded with toppings, on top of a perfect amount of cheese and an absolutely delicious sauce. They do this style of pizza better than anyone else in the area I've ever had. The pizza's awesome, but the Stromboli might be even better. It's like their pizza, folded over, with even more garlic. And their garlic bread is good too. But if you order it, spring for the cheese. This place is so good, that we've ordered from there as least once a week every week since they've opened. You will not be disappointed!

Been watching and waiting for them to be open! We got a cheese pizza and a meat lovers both with extra cheese. They were absolutely delicious. Perfectly cooked and the sauce is wonderful. Fries were great. The garlic rolls were a little overdone and hard. But overall, we will definitely be ordering again!